Cleveland won its first series against the Rays since August 2017 and ended a long stretch of games on the road with a 6-5 record.
Reliever Kirk McCarty (2-2) allowed one run, four hits and two walks in 3 1/3 innings. Emmanuel Clase worked the ninth to get his 23rd save.
McClanahan (10-4) gave up five runs, seven hits and three walks with four strikeouts over 4 1/3 innings – tying season-low. His major-league best 1.76 ERA climbed to 2.07, and the lefty had his streak of going six or more innings with two earned runs or fewer stop at 13 games.
David Peralta, acquired from Arizona on Saturday, started in left field and went 1 for 4 in his Rays debut. Tampa Bay is 3-7 since the All-Star break.
Ryan Thompson replaced McClanahan with the bases loaded and one out in the fifth and after getting an out gave up the go-ahead hit to Hedges.
The Guardians went up 3-0 in the second when Myles Straw had a two-run single and Jose Ramirez picked up his 84th RBI with a base hit.
Tampa Bay responded in the bottom of the second when Isaac Paredes hit a leadoff double, went to third on Bryan Shaw‘s wild pitch and scored the first of two Tampa Bay runs when catcher Hedges was charged with an error for an errant throw to third.
Ji-Man Choi tied it at 3-3 on a fourth-inning sacrifice fly. He also had a run-scoring grounder during the second.
Shaw allowed two runs, two hits and three walks over two innings in second consecutive start after 732 relief consecutive appearances.
Guardians rookie Steven Kwan extended his hitting streak to 14 games on a first-inning bunt single. He also threw out Brandon Lowe, who tried to score from second on Randy Arozarena‘s fifth-inning single.
BY THE NUMBERS
Peralta wore wearing No. 6, while INF Taylor Walls switched from 6 to 0. Peralta said 6 was his first big-league number and that he will talk with Walls to “take care of him” for giving up the number.
Walls and OF Mallex Smith (2017-18) are the only Tampa Bay players to wear No. 0.
Guardians: Manager Terry Francona said 1B Josh Naylor was feeling better one day after experiencing numbness in his surgically repaired right ankle. . 1B Owen Miller (bruised right forearm) didn’t play.
Rays: Manager Kevin Cash said the reports on closer Nick Anderson‘s (right elbow surgery) first outing with Triple-A Durham Saturday night were encouraging.
Guardians: RHP Cal Quantrill (7-5) is scheduled to start Monday night’s game against Arizona.