One Hall of Fame voter chose not to submit his ballot at all because of Mariano Rivera

Christian Petersen/Getty Images
51 Comments

Former Yankees closer Mariano Rivera is recognized by most as the greatest closer in baseball history. The role of “closer” has only really existed in the last five decades, but Rivera — with a record 652 saves and a career 2.21 ERA — has always seemed a cut above the rest. Across his 19-season career, he finished with an ERA below 2.00 11 times. He was even more vicious in the postseason, limiting the opposition to 11 earned runs across 141 innings in the playoffs — a 0.70 ERA.

Rivera is a shoo-in for the Hall of Fame. The only unknown is what percentage of the electorate will vote for him. There has never been a unanimously-elected player. The closest anyone has come to unanimity is Ken Griffey, Jr., who garnered 99.32 percent of the vote in 2016.

In part because of Rivera, one writer with a Hall of Fame vote, Bill Ballou of the Telegram & Gazette, has chosen not to submit his ballot at all. In a column published on Saturday, Ballou explained that while Rivera indeed was great, he has a distaste for the concept of the “closer” role and finds closers in general overrated. Ballou points out that, despite a 5.90 ERA in this past postseason, Craig Kimbrel was 6-for-6 in save situations. Ballou also correctly points out that closers have a comparatively easier job than many other pitchers: they come into the game with the bases empty, typically pitch only one inning, and don’t have to go through the lineup multiple times like starting pitchers. Ballou’s overarching theme is that just because something happens at the end of a game doesn’t make it more important than the events that preceded it. In other words, closers get a lot more credit than they deserve.

Ballou’s point is one that a lot of Sabermetric-leaning analysts have pointed out for a while, so he isn’t exploring new land here. He is, however, using it to justify a controversial decision to abstain from voting entirely. This is different than submitting a blank ballot because a blank ballot would be considered as not having chosen to vote for all of the players, ruining everyone’s chances — particularly Rivera’s — of unanimity. Abstention simply takes that responsibility away from Ballou while still allowing him to make his point.

Along with Griffey, a handful of players who were eligible for the Hall of Fame in the last couple of decades were thought to have had the chance to go in unanimously. Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, Greg Maddux, Cal Ripken, Jr., and Tony Gwynn, just to check a few names off the list. All came close to varying degrees, but for each player, there was at least one voter who felt he shouldn’t go in unanimously. Recognizing that makes the hand-wringing over entering the Hall of Fame unanimously — and, on a similar wavelength, being elected on the first ballot — pointless. Rivera still likely doesn’t get elected unanimously. And no matter what percentage of the vote a player gets and no matter if it’s the player’s first or 10th time on ballot, he gets the same plaque and the same celebration in Cooperstown. Ballou’s column has drummed up a bit of controversy, but it really shouldn’t have. And he shouldn’t have felt the pressure to have had to decide to abstain from participating rather than, in the minds of many people, tar a candidate’s path to the Hall of Fame.

Jacob deGrom, oft-injured Rangers ace, to have season-ending right elbow surgery

rangers degrom
Charles LeClaire/USA TODAY Sports
2 Comments

ARLINGTON, Texas — The Texas Rangers signed Jacob deGrom to a $185 million, five-year deal in free agency last winter hoping the two-time NL Cy Young Award winner could help them get back to the playoffs for the first time since 2016 and make a push toward winning a World Series.

They also knew the risks, with the pitcher coming off two injury-plagued seasons with the New York Mets.

Even with deGrom sidelined since late April, the AL West-leading Rangers are off to the best start in franchise history – but now will be without their prized acquisition until at least next year. The team said Tuesday that deGrom will have season-ending surgery next week to repair a torn ulnar collateral ligament in his right elbow.

“We’ve got a special group here and to not be able to be out there and help them win, that stinks,” deGrom said, pausing several times with tears in his eyes. “Wanting to be out there and helping the team, it’s a disappointment.”

General manager Chris Young said Tuesday the decision on surgery came after an MRI on deGrom’s ailing right elbow, but the extent of what is required might not be determined until the operation is performed next week.

Tommy John surgery, in which the damaged ligament is replaced, is often needed to fix a torn UCL, but Young and the Rangers didn’t go as far as saying the pitcher would have that particular procedure. After being drafted by the New York Mets in 2010, deGrom made six starts in the minors that summer before needing Tommy John surgery and missing all of 2011, three years before his big league debut.

DeGrom last pitched April 28 against the New York Yankees, when he exited early because of injury concerns for the second time in a span of three starts. The announcement about surgery came a day after deGrom was transferred to the 60-day injured list.

Young said the latest MRI showed more inflammation and significant structural damage in the ligament that wasn’t there on the scan after deGrom left the game against the Yankees.

“The results of that MRI show that we have not made progress. And in fact, we’ve identified some damage to the ligament,” Young said. “It’s obviously a tough blow for Jacob, for certainly the Rangers. But we do feel this is what is right for Jacob in his career. We’re confident he’ll make a full recovery.”

Young and deGrom, who turns 35 later this month, said the goal is for the pitcher to return near the end of next season. Both said they were glad to have clarity on what was wrong with the elbow.

Texas won all six games started by deGrom (2-0), but the right-hander threw only 30 1/3 innings. He has a 2.67 ERA with 45 strikeouts and four walks. He threw 3 2/3 scoreless innings against the Yankees in his last start before leaving because of discomfort in his arm.

The Rangers went into Tuesday night’s game against St. Louis with a 39-20 record, the first time they were 19 games over .500 since the end of 2016, their last winning season.

Before going home to Florida over the weekend for the birth of his third child, deGrom threw his fifth bullpen last Wednesday in Detroit.

“I’d have days where I’d feel really good, days where I didn’t feel great. So I was kind of riding a roller coaster there for a little bit,” deGrom said. “They said originally there, we just saw some inflammation. … Getting an MRI right after you pitch, I feel like anybody would have inflammation. So, you know, I was hoping that that would get out of there and I would be fine. But it just didn’t work out that way.”

DeGrom spent his first nine big league seasons with the Mets, but was limited by injuries to 156 1/3 innings over 26 starts during his last two years in New York.

He had a career-low 1.08 ERA over 92 innings in 2021 before missing the final three months of the season with right forearm tightness and a sprained elbow.

The four-time All-Star didn’t make his first big league start last year until Aug. 2 after being shut down late in spring training because of a stress reaction in his right scapula.

His latest injury almost surely will trigger Texas’ conditional option on deGrom’s contract for 2028.

The option takes effect if deGrom has Tommy John surgery on his right elbow from 2023-26 or has any right elbow or shoulder injury that causes him to be on the IL for any period of 130 consecutive days during any season or 186 days in a row during any service period.

The conditional option would be for $20 million, $30 million or $37 million, depending on deGrom’s performance during the contract and health following the 2027 season.

“I feel bad for Jake. If I know Jake, he’ll have the surgery and come back and finish his career strong,” second-year Mets manager Buck Showalter said. “I know how much it means to him. He enjoys pitching. It’s certainly sad news for all of us.”