AP Photo/Francois Mori

Stephen King doesn’t like the netting at Fenway Park

23 Comments

Author Stephen King penned a column for the Boston Globe, published on Sunday, in which he argues against the protective netting installed at Fenway Park. As a result of some recent incidents in which fans have been severely injured by foul balls and shattered bats, Major League Baseball recommended that teams extend the netting at their ballparks.

The change wasn’t met with a warm welcome, but players seem to like it. King’s concerns about the netting echo what has already been said by scores of fans and ultimately I find his arguments not very compelling. I’d like to address his arguments.

According to a Bloomberg News report, 1,750 fans are injured in game-related incidents every year. That’s more than the number of batters hit by pitches (about 1,500, according to the Elias Sports Bureau). But almost 74 million fans attended MLB games in 2015, so the chances of being struck by a piece of bat or a foul line drive are pretty slim. Right up there with getting struck by lightning, I’d say.

The risk may be low, but it’s non-zero. Perhaps King doesn’t feel like it’s worth taking precautions for such a low-risk event, but his risk tolerance — in general, or just on this particular issue — may be greater than others’. The odds of transferring a life-threatening illness with unwashed hands is relatively low, but we still as a society expect each other to use soap and water after visiting the restroom.

There are questions inherent in the decision to net, and I think they’re bigger than baseball. Like when does protection become overprotection? Is the safety of a fan at a public event like a baseball game the responsibility of the organization putting on that event? (According to the back of every MLB ticket sold, the fan is responsible.) When do safety precautions begin to steal away the pure joy of being there?

We could let the free market decide, right? I’m no free market advocate, though most seem to be. If fans stop showing up because the netting makes the viewing experience so unpleasant, then teams will take down the netting. Most likely, though, fans will complain about it for a short while, but then they won’t even notice it. One typically has a screen behind paned windows in a house — how noticeable are the grids on those screens when you’re looking through them, even close-up? Same thing.

Also, Craig wrote about the “back of the ticket” issue a couple years ago. It’s a legal “safe harbor”, to use Craig’s term, that’s gradually been made weaker, especially with all of the prompting to use your cell phones at ballparks these days. Get out your cell phone to check out the MLB app, or order food, or take a picture of your ticket to enter a raffle, or provide feedback about your experience. Hey, check out what’s on the big screen in the left field bleachers! Hey, look at that dancing mascot! What game? The ballpark experience is one of myriad distractions and it’s quite unfair to pin all of the responsibility for that distraction on the fan.

That netting may be a fine mesh, but you’re still looking through a barrier instead of right at the thing you came to see. Which means you’d do almost as well to sit home watching the game on TV.

Isn’t it selfish to say that other fans should have to endure risk to preserve King’s pristine viewing experience? Why can’t he sacrifice an infinitesimal amount of viewing pleasure to keep his neighbors — the ones he wrote about glowingly in the second paragraph of his column — assured of their safety?

But if we are not to be a nation of overgrown children being cared for by various forms of the MLB brass (“for our own good,” of course), we have to take at least some responsibility when we attend a public event.

This is the most-cited argument used by netting detractors. In a perfect world? No one is distracted at baseball games because they got a text message or needed to get another level in Candy Crush. In the real world, though? Sometimes people have loved ones in the hospital and they’re getting status updates, or the boss sends an urgent work e-mail, or the nephew just wanted to say hi. Sometimes your neighbor in the seat next to you wants to chat about the Patriots or show you a picture of his son in a Little League game. Just because one looks down at a phone for a couple of seconds doesn’t mean one deserves to be hit in the skull by a line drive foul ball. King didn’t say this explicitly, but it’s the implication of every “personal responsibility” argument.

Sometimes parents bring their young kids to games. Should we expect a five-year-old to sit still and focus on the game for three and a half hours? Should we expect those parents to never break focus when their kids try to scamper off elsewhere, or spill a soda, or get mustard all over their coats? You can take all of the personal responsibility you want, sometimes you’re still going to get distracted. You should be able to be distracted without fearing that a life-threatening missile could soon be headed your way.

Also, there’s something almost ludicrous about wrapping America’s baseball stadiums in protective gauze when any idiot with a grudge can buy a gun and shoot a bunch of people. I’d much rather see some action taken on that little problem.

This is a false choice. They’re not even related, and we can tackle both issues!

King closes out his column saying that he’s still going to show up to Fenway Park everyday anyway. If the netting is really such a big deal, speak with your wallet. Don’t attend games. If most fans feel the way King does, then this should make teams take notice. My guess is that King won’t even notice the netting a couple weeks from now.

Royals outfielder Gordon to retire after 14 seasons

Getty Images
1 Comment

Kansas City Royals outfielder Alex Gordon, the former first-round pick whose rollercoaster career took him from near bust to All-Star and Gold Glove winner, announced Thursday he will retire after the season.

Gordon was the second overall pick in the 2005 first-year player draft following a standout career at Nebraska, where he won the Golden Spikes Award as the best amateur in baseball. He made his big league debut two years later and, after a few years shuttling back and forth to the minors, moved from third base to the outfield and finally found success.

He wound up playing his entire 14-year career in Kansas City, joining only George Brett and Frank White as position players with that much longevity with the franchise. He heads into a weekend four-game series against Detroit with the third-most walks (682), fourth-most homers (190), fifth-most doubles (357) and sixth-most games played (1,749) in club history.

The three-time All-Star also holds the dubious distinction of being the Royals’ career leader in getting hit by pitches.

While he never quite hit with the kind of average the Royals hoped he would, Gordon did through sheer grit turn himself into one of the best defensive players in the game. He is the only outfielder to earn seven Gold Gloves in a nine-year span, a number that trails only White’s eight for the most in franchise history, and there are enough replays of him crashing into the outfield wall at Kauffman Stadium or throwing out a runner at the plate to run for hours.

Gordon won the first of three defensive player of the year awards in 2014, when he helped Kansas City return to the World Series for the first time since its 1985 championship. The Royals wound up losing to the Giants in a seven-game thriller, but they returned to the Fall Classic the following year and beat the Mets in five games to win the World Series.

It was during the 2015 that Gordon hit one of the iconic homers in Royals history. His tying shot off Mets closer Jeurys Familia in Game 1 forced extra innings, and the Royals won in 14 to set the tone for the rest of the World Series.

Gordon signed a one-year contract to return this season, and he never considered opting out when the coronavirus pandemic caused spring training to be halted and forced Major League Baseball to play a dramatically reduced 60-game schedule.

___

More AP MLB: https://apnews.com/MLB and https://twitter.com/AP_Sports