The benches cleared in Friday’s Giants-Rangers game

208 Comments

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: Madison Bumgarner got mad at a player for tossing his bat in frustration. Delino DeShields popped out to second base to end the fourth inning. He was upset at himself, so he tossed his bat with some oomph. This didn’t sit well with Bumgarner, who jawed at DeShields, causing the benches to empty. He got into a shouting match with Adrian Beltre amid the altercation.

Among the players Bumgarner has taken issue with for reacting in any way at all to something that happened on the field:

  • Jesus Guzman, May 2013: Bumgarner didn’t like Guzman’s smug celebration after hitting a home run in a game he didn’t start, so he intentionally threw at Guzman the next day. [Sports Illustrated]
  • Yasiel Puig, May 2014: Bumgarner didn’t like Puig’s bat flip after he hit a home run, so he yelled at the outfielder. [San Francisco Chronicle]
  • Puig again, September 2014: Bumgarner hit Puig with a pitch and he didn’t like how Puig reacted to that, so he needlessly escalated a confrontation. [HardballTalk]
  • Alex Guerrero, April 2015: Bumgarner didn’t like Alex Guerrero expressing dissatisfaction after popping up a pitch, so he shouted, “You’re not that good” at him. [ESPN]
  • Carlos Gomez, May 2015: Bumgarner didn’t like that Gomez shouted in frustration after fouling off a pitch he thought he should have hit better, so the lefty tossed his next pitch way inside, nearly hitting Gomez. [San Francisco Chronicle]
  • Delino DeShields, July, 2015: This what one might describe as a “trend”.

Perhaps manager Bruce Bochy should have a talk with the lefty.

The Cubs played under protest after Joe Maddon disputed an ‘illegal’ pitching motion

Joe Maddon
AP Images
1 Comment

The Cubs found themselves in a disadvantageous position toward the end of their 5-2 loss to the Nationals on Saturday. Down by three in the ninth, they were finally looking to gain some ground against closer Sean Doolittle after wearying themselves against Stephen Strasburg for the first eight innings of the game. Instead, the game ended under protest when Cubs skipper Joe Maddon took umbrage with Doolittle’s delivery:

The issue appeared to stem from the motion Doolittle made with his left foot, a kind of “toe-tapping” gesture that Maddon believed had previously been made illegal. The official rules state that a pitcher may not take a second step toward home plate during his delivery, a stipulation that had previously been violated by Cubs’ pitcher Carl Edwards Jr.:

Comparing the two motions, however, one would be hard-pressed to characterize Doolittle’s tapping motion as a full step toward the plate. Maddon clearly didn’t see it that way, and emerged from the dugout to dispute the pitcher’s delivery twice. Following Doolittle’s first-pitch strike to Albert Almora, the manager informed home-plate umpire Sam Holbrook that the Cubs would play the remainder of the game under protest.

An official decision has not yet been announced regarding the illegality of the delivery and the validity of the Cubs’ protest. According to league rules, “the game will not be replayed unless it is also determined that the violation adversely affected the protesting team’s chances of winning.”

During the inning in question, however, the umpiring crew allowed Doolittle to continue his delivery. He helped secure the Nationals’ 5-2 win after inducing a groundout from Almora, striking out Kyle Schwarber, and getting a game-ending pop-out from Kris Bryant.

After the game, both Holbrook and Doolittle took issue with Maddon’s protest.

“In that moment, he’s not trying to do anything other than rattle me,” Doolittle told reporters. “And it was kind of tired. I don’t know, sometimes he has to remind people how smart he is and how much he pays attention to the game. So he put his stamp on it, for sure.”

Holbrook, meanwhile, said Doolittle did “absolutely nothing illegal at all.”