The first overturned call via replay happened yesterday … and the first needless delay

46 Comments

It wasn’t exciting, but a call was overturned by replay yesterday. It was a call on second base in which the fielder bobbled the ball, the runner was called out nonetheless, and then upon replay the umps reversed themselves:

[mlbvideo id=”31504257″ width=”400″ height=”224″ /]

Note that the replay itself — from the time the review was initiated until the safe call was quick. Only about a minute. However, the review was bookended by managers on the field, first with Lloyd McClendon arguing that maybe his man was safe then with Mike Scioscia arguing about the overturned call. So in all the process took around three minutes. And, oh, I thought managers were not allowed to argue replay decisions, so why wasn’t Scioscia immediately run from the game?

The technology appears to be working well so far. The human part of it all looks like it could be a drag. Baseball needs to get tough about the arguing immediately before it becomes a common problem.