MLB denies Mets’ appeal for R.A. Dickey no-hitter

11 Comments

As expected, MLB has denied the Mets’ appeal that R.A. Dickey’s one-hitter Wednesday be changed to a no-hitter after the fact.

They asked the league to consider changing B.J. Upton’s first-inning infield hit, which proved to be the Rays’ only one off Dickey, into an error on third baseman David Wright.

Dickey himself said the idea of overruling the original call to give him a no-hitter “would be weird” and “would be a little bit cheap.” He also correctly noted that the entire scope of the game and the amount of pressure on him would have changed, making an after-the-fact switch problematic on several levels.

And apparently MLB agreed. Or maybe they just thought Upton’s hit was actually a hit. Either way Dickey officially threw a one-hitter, improving to 10-1 with a 2.20 ERA, and Johan Santana’s no-hitter two weeks ago remains the only one in Mets history.