Andy Pettitte allows four runs in return to major leagues

22 Comments

Andy Pettitte took the mound Sunday at Yankee Stadium for the first time since October 18, 2010.

What followed was a good but not great reunion.

After opening with 3 2/3 innings of hitless ball against the Mariners, Pettitte surrendered a walk to Jesus Montero with two outs in the fourth inning and Justin Smoak followed with a blast to left field.

The typically-light-hitting M’s would score two more runs in the sixth inning courtesy of a Casper Wells home run and wound up tallying a total of seven hits and three walks in Pettitte’s 6 1/3 innings of work.

Pettitte did some nice things and got a couple of booming ovations from the Bronx crowd, but he was probably hoping for better in his first start back. He wound up throwing 94 pitches, 60 of which went for strikes.

The 39-year-old southpaw will get another chance to impress on Friday evening against the Reds.