A position-by-position breakdown of the best players not in the Hall of Fame

25 Comments

Over at Baseball Prospectus Jay Jaffe runs down the best players not in the Hall of Fame by position. At least the first half of them (this is the first part of a series).

It’s a maddening list so far. Not so much for the first name listed — in  many cases they are players like Mike Piazza and Craig Biggio who will almost certainly make it soon — but for the second.  Guys like Bobby Grich, Dick Allen and Ted Simmons who never got a real hard look by the Hall of Fame voters.

Oh, and Darrell Evans? My god that dude was good. And I bet if you asked 100 baseball fans under 30 if they knew who he was, the low percentage of affirmative answers would drive you to despair. Or at least me.