Dear BBWAA: please lower your Hall of Fame voting standards

32 Comments

Dave Cameron makes a well-reasoned appeal to the BBWAA to lower its Hall of Fame voting standards and let more dudes into Cooperstown:

To me, an inclusive hall is a better hall, and one I’d be more interested in visiting. I won’t begrudge someone who holds a small hall perspective, but I would ask them to perhaps consider to what end they’re in favor of exclusivity. What is the benefit of fewer people remembering how great Tim Raines really was?

There’s even a quasi-endorsement of Bill Simmons’ famous Hall of Fame Pyramid thing from several years ago in which players are ranked as immortals on down to the merely great.

It’ll never happen, but Dave makes a great case for a larger Hall of Fame.

Meanwhile: check out this fictitious Hall of Fame voter’s ballot and tell me that it doesn’t read like a lot of real ones you’ve read before.