So who gave Ian Kennedy a first place Cy Young vote?

15 Comments

I am a much older and wiser man than I used to be and thus I no longer make a big fuss out of the actual vote tabulations when it comes to awards voting and that sort of thing.*

But some things are confusing, such as how Ian Kennedy got a first place vote for the NL Cy Young Award.

Not to slam Kennedy. Not to make a federal case out of it. Just noting that Clayton Kershaw, Roy Halladay and Cliff Lee all had, by just about every measure, a better year than Kennedy did and that Kennedy’s lone first place vote certainly seemed like an outlier.  And when you see an outlier like that, it’s natural to want to know who cast it.

An Arizona guy, maybe? A bit of a homer vote?  It’s happened before.

Not this time, though.  The Kennedy voter was John Maffei of the North County Times near San Diego. Maffei doesn’t have a column up explaining his vote — voters certainly aren’t obligated to do so — but it does seem like a strange one.

 

*Note: this sentence will be deleted prior to the week-to-ten days I spend raging about the Hall of Fame voting.