The Tigers want a leadoff hitter, but Jose Reyes doesn’t make sense

15 Comments

Jerry Crasnick of ESPN.com said today that the Tigers offseason priority is to find a leadoff hitter.  Not surprisingly, Crasnick says that Jose Reyes is a “dream candidate.”

Just about anyone I talk to about the Tigers seems to think that too.  The only problem with it is that the Tigers already have $90 million committed to just nine players, and by the time they fill out their roster, pay the necessary raises for 2012 and all of that, they’re looking at something like $120 million at least. Probably a bit more. They’re even still paying Gary Sheffield for cryin’ out loud.

Oh, and they still have Jhonny Peralta, who just had an awesome season and is under contract through 2012 and has a club option for 2013 that is exceedingly affordable.

To be sure, Mike Ilitch has shown in the past that he’ll spend money if he thinks it’ll make the difference.  But it’s a 95-win team already and they have shortstop covered.  If the Tigers are going to spend money, they should spend it elsewhere.