Is it time to hit Alex Rodriguez eighth again?

39 Comments

After the Yankees finally got their first hit off Max Scherzer — a Robinson Cano flare to left in the sixth inning — Alex Rodriguez came up for the third time in Sunday’s Game 2 and popped out to shallow right.  He’s now 0-for-7 with a walk in the series.

This isn’t about A-Rod choking.  This is about the future Hall of Famer being banged up and ineffective.  He hit .191/.345/.353 with three homers in 68 at-bats after coming off the disabled list in August. He finished the season 6-for-32 with one homer in nine games after returning from a thumb injury.

So, it’s past time for Joe Girardi to react. If Rodriguez starts hitting, he can always be moved back up to the cleanup spot. However, he has no business being there right now, and one can expect right-handers to start pitching around No. 3 hitter Robinson Cano if the Yankees leave him there. Mark Teixeira is the better option right now.