Phillies’ protest of Sunday’s loss to the Marlins denied

48 Comments

As expected.

The Phillies’ protest of Sunday’s 14-inning loss to the Marlins over what appeared to be the improper use of replay on a fan interference call has been denied.

Major League Baseball made the announcement after the play was reviewed by Joe Torre, the executive vice president for baseball operations.

The Phillies protested after Hunter Pence was ruled out on fan interference after initially being awarded a double, a ruling change that cost the team two runs. The score was tied at 2 when Pence hit a fly ball to right-center. A spectator leaned over the outfield railing and tried to catch the ball with his cap. Marlins right fielder Bryan Petersen tried to make the catch, but his glove brushed the fan’s cap, and the ball went for an apparent double. Following a video review, the umpires called Pence out.

The umpiring crew defended the call by saying it was a home run in doubt.  Replay rules do not allow for the review of possible doubles.