J.J. Hardy homers to remind Twins of mistake they made letting him go

6 Comments

Last night the Twins were reminded of their biggest offseason mistake when Orioles shortstop J.J. Hardy homered in his return to Minnesota.

Hardy, who was traded for a pair of mid-level prospects after the Twins decided they wanted to add more “speed” to the middle infield, now has 24 homers for the Orioles, which is the most by an AL East shortstop since Miguel Tejada back in 2006.

Hardy has 24 homers in 383 at-bats while the Twins’ entire infield, including everyone to play first base, second base, shortstop, or third base, has 37 homers in 2,328 at-bats. And their shortstops have hit .233 with three homers.

Ron Gardenhire claimed yesterday that Hardy “was probably going to be non-tendered” by the Twins if they hadn’t traded him to Baltimore, except they actually tendered Hardy a contract on December 2 and didn’t trade him until December 9. Perhaps they already had the framework of a deal in place, in which case Gardenhire is telling the truth about their misguided plan to cut one of the best shortstops in baseball for nothing. Ultimately the only difference is the degree of the Twins’ ineptitude.

Baltimore immediately liked what they saw in Hardy, signing him to a three-year, $22 million extension.