Andre Ethier to take Shane Victorino’s spot on NL All-Star team

6 Comments

A little comparison…

Corner outfielders on the NL All-Star team
Carlos Beltran
Lance Berkman
Ryan Braun
Jay Bruce
Matt Holliday
Hunter Pence
Justin Upton

Center fielders on the NL All-Star team
Matt Kemp

So, of course the league today named Andre Ethier the replacement for the injured Shane Victorino on the NL squad.  Because what the team really needed was a sixth right fielder, while Andrew McCutchen gets left out again.

To review, McCutchen is hitting .291/.389/.491 with 12 homers and 48 RBI this year while playing a very good center field.  Ethier is hitting .313/.382/.451 with seven homers and 42 RBI while playing a pretty poor right field.

Ethier was the better hitter in previous years, but after factoring in defense and baserunning, McCutchen rated as the superior player even before lapping Ethier this season.

Anyway, I don’t want to come off as wholly anti-Ethier here.  It’s just that McCutchen was deserving a spot on the team when it was originally announced, he was deserving of being included in the Final Vote and he certainly makes a whole lot more sense than Ethier now given the composition of the squad.