Benches empty in Indians-Yankees game after Teixeira HBP

27 Comments

It never came to blows between the Red Sox and Yankees this week, but it almost did with the Tribe in town tonight.  After Fausto Carmona hit Mark Teixeira with a pitch in the second inning, the benches and the bullpens emptied, though no blows were exchanged.

The Indians were down 4-0 when a wild Carmona drilled Teixeira.  The previous batter, Curtis Granderson, had just homered.  There probably wasn’t a whole lot of intention on Carmona’s part. He struggled with his control right from the start tonight, walking three batters in the first inning.

But intentional or not, Teixeira did take offense.  He had just just gotten hit by the Red Sox on Tuesday, knocking him out of the game with a bruised knee.  Carmona’s plunking made it seven HBPs for him this season, and while Teixeira has always crowded the plate, that’s well ahead of his usual pace.  His career high for HBPs is 14, established in his rookie season in 2003.  He was hit 13 times last year.

Carmona and Teixeira jawed afterwards, and while it didn’t seem like anyone on either team wanted to throw a punch, managers Manny Acta and Joe Girardi got into a very heated discussion in the middle of the infield before things eventually calmed down.

This is just the opener of a four-game series, so there could be more to come.