Josh Hamilton wins the AL MVP Award

26 Comments

The voting for the final award of the year is in and the trophy goes to Josh Hamilton, who beat out Miquel Cabrera and Robinson Cano for the AL MVP award.  Hamilton received 22 of the 28 first place votes. Cabrera had five and Jose Bautista — who finished fourth overall — had one.

I think Hamilton, Cabrera and, to a slightly lesser extent Cano, were all plausible choices, and if either Cabrera or Cano had won there wouldn’t be a ton of room for squawking.

Hamilton, when healthy, was probably the best player in the American League this year. But Cabrera was close and had a few more plate appearances.  Cano trailed them offensively, but was tremendously valuable on defensive and, for long stretches, carried a Yankees team that saw slumps and injuries from putative big guns Alex Rodriguez, Mark Teixeira, Derek Jeter and Jorge Posada. If I had a vote I would have given it to Hamilton, but again, this is not a year where my favored guy not getting it would have been an atrocity.

As for these results: I think that both Joey Votto’s comfortable win yesterday and Hamilton’s today shows us that voters still think of the MVP award as very much a team award, not a purely individual one. Votto’s and Pujols’ years were virtually identical, but Votto’s overwhelming margin of victory was attributable to the fact that the Reds beat the Cardinals. Some voters came right out and said so.  I think a lot of that was at work here as well, with team results hurting Cabrera while helping Hamilton and Cano.

Which did not, it should be noted, lead to any sort of injustice this season.  But it has in the past when there weren’t as many obvious good choices on contenders, and could in the future. And that’s somewhat troubling to me.  I appreciate that there are multiple definitions of the word “valuable,” but how voters have come to view the team’s overall performance as having such significance to an award that we all appreciate is an individual award is baffling.

But let’s leave that battle for another day. Today we should (a) congratulate Josh Hamilton for his award; and (b) congratulate the BBWAA for — once again — doing what I feel was a pretty damn fine job on the awards voting.

Now, if we can only do something about those gold glove voters . . .

Report: Joe Girardi withdraws from consideration as Reds’ next manager

Joe Girardi
Getty Images
Leave a comment

Former Yankees skipper Joe Girardi has reportedly withdrawn his name for consideration in the Reds’ managerial search, according to a report from Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. Per Rosenthal, Girardi was considered the frontrunner for the position, but elected to keep his current gig as an MLB Network analyst for the foreseeable future.

The 54-year-old skipper holds a lifetime 988-794 record in 11 years with the Marlins and Yankees. He cut his teeth on the Marlins’ 2006 season, during which the team skidded to a fourth-place finish in the NL East, then helped the Yankees to 10 consecutive winning records and a World Series title. While Mark Feinsand of MLB.com adds that Girardi “absolutely wants to manage again,” it’s unclear when and with whom he might choose to do so.

Without Girardi, the Reds still have several candidates left in play, not the least of whom is retired MLB third baseman David Bell. Bell previously served as the Reds’ Double-A and Triple-A manager from 2008-2012 and racked up a cumulative 227-332 record during that span. His resume also includes several coaching positions with the Cubs and Cardinals, and most recently, a role as VP of player development for the Giants in 2018. As Rosenthal points out, however, the 46-year-old coach is hardly a lock for a managerial spot with the Reds, as he’s also made a strong impression on the Blue Jays, Rangers, and Giants this fall.