General manager Walt Jocketty indicated yesterday that the Reds are likely to decline their $4 million option on Orlando Cabrera for next season, but may be interested in re-signing the veteran shortstop for a lesser salary.
Cabrera hit just .263/.303/.354 for a .657 OPS that ranked fourth-worst among all NL hitters and at age 35 has lost most of his range defensively, so the Reds are right to think he’s not worth $4 million in 2011. On the other hand the buyout for his option is $1 million, so they seem unlikely to save a whole lot by declining the option and re-signing him.
Cincinnati would likely be better off simply cutting Cabrera loose, investing the $3 million saved elsewhere, and handing shortstop over to 27-year-old Paul Janish. He hit .260/.338/.385 in 228 plate appearances this season while often subbing for an injured Cabrera and is superior defensively, all for around $400,000.