Albert Pujols won "NL player of the month" for August while the Cardinals went 11-15

20 Comments

Albert Pujols has been named the National League’s player of the month for August, and rightfully so. He hit .379 and slugged .777 during the month, smacking 11 homers and eight doubles in 103 at-bats while posting a 1.230 OPS in 26 games.
And the Cardinals went 11-15.
All of which says two things, to me at least. One is that the rest of the Cardinals are really, really struggling. That’s not exactly breaking news given that they’ve fallen eight games back of the Reds in the NL Central and are now just 69-62 overall, but the point is hammered home when they have a .423 winning percentage despite the guy in the middle of their lineup hitting like Babe Ruth (or, like Albert Pujols).
Beyond that, it can serve as yet another reminder of how silly it is to let team success factor into individual award voting at the end of the season. Pujols may not be the best player in the league when all is said and done this season because right now Joey Votto is neck and neck with him, but if Pujols is the best it would be crazy to let the Cardinals not making the playoffs keep him from another deserved MVP.
Pujols did everything he could possibly do to help the Cardinals last month and they still had a losing record. The fact that his teammates collectively stunk doesn’t make what he did any more or less valuable, and that applies to full seasons every bit as much as it does to months. I’m really looking forward to the Triple Crown race between Pujols and Votto, and the MVP voting should be interesting as well, but I’m hoping Votto doesn’t get extra credit for his teammates performing better.