HBT Poll: Is Johnny Damon a Hall of Famer?

24 Comments

Johnny Damon got his 2,500th hit last night.  I don’t know if I’d bet the farm on it, but there’s at least a chance he hits 3,000 before he’s done.  If he does that — or if he even gets close — someone’s going to make the Hall of Fame case for him.  Heck, some people who overvalue World Series rings may be making the case already.

My view: Damon has probably been an underrated player for most of his career, but if things break right for him, he may wind up being the test case for a guy with 3,000 hits not making the Hall.  But that’s just, like, my opinion man.  I want to know what you think.

And yes, I know this isn’t scientific, but I bet I’m drawing from a smarter sample than that which comprises the actual Hall of Fame electorate: