Mariotti: the media should not vote for postseason awards

4 Comments

I disagree with Jay Mariotti on just about everything on the planet — and the multiple paragraphs he devotes to PED politics in his latest column are rather boring and unenlightening. But the point he started with — sports writers shouldn’t vote for postseason awards — is one worthy of consideration.

I don’t know who else is in a good position to decide who should be the MVP and all of that, and the usual alternatives cited — players, coaches, fans — are probably worse choices than what we have now, but I think Mariotti makes some pretty valid points about conflicts of interest and writers not always taking their job seriously when it comes to voting for awards.

I think the best move would be to create some panel that includes working media and some various experts.  How you go about picking its members I have no idea, but I think that relying so much on beat guys who depend upon awards candidates for the access they need to do their job is problematic.