Tag: Julio Lugo

Erick Aybar

Erick Aybar settled way too cheap


More power to him if Erick Aybar loves Southern California and didn’t want to play anywhere else. He still should have done better than $35 million for four years in his new extension with the Angels.

$8.75 million per year is less than Julio Lugo got in his four-year deal with the Red Sox six years ago. It’s less than a well past his prime Edgar Renteria got from the Giants in a two-year deal for 2009-10. It’s barely more than Cristian Guzman earned in 2009-10.

And in case no one has noticed, the price tags have generally gone up since then. Aybar’s only rival at shortstop in free agency this winter would have been Stephen Drew, and at this point, there’s no telling if Drew is going to be a viable long-term shortstop after last year’s ankle injury. It’s possible no other starting shortstops will hit free agency this winter: Jhonny Peralta’s option is almost certain to be picked up by the Tigers, and Jason Bartlett and Alex Gonzalez both have 2013 options that figure to vest if they stay healthy.

Aybar may not be thought of as a star, but he certainly ranks among the game’s top 10 shortstops with his plus glove and .695 career OPS. Hitting free agency at age 29, he probably would have gotten $50 million for five years as a minimum. Instead, he settled for $35 million and didn’t even get no-trade protection in the bargain. Angels fans should be thrilled.

Indians’ deal with Julio Lugo has “fallen apart”

Julio Lugo

Last week the Indians signed veteran infielder Julio Lugo to a minor-league contract, or so they thought.

Jordan Bastian of MLB.com reports that the deal has “fallen apart” and the Indians no longer expect to sign Lugo, who would have competed for a bench spot in spring training at age 36.

He would have been unlikely to make the team anyway, as Lugo saw very limited action in the majors with the Braves last season while hitting .136 and hit just .249 with a .581 OPS in 93 games for the Orioles in 2010.

Mostly it just seems weird that negotiations for a minor-league contract could break down, because there really isn’t a whole lot to negotiate other than maybe an invitation to spring training or an opt-out clause if he’s not in the majors by a certain date.

Or maybe someone in the Indians’ front office realized what was happening and said: “Wait, is this the same Julio Lugo? The 36-year-old one?”

UPDATE: Bastian follows up to say that Lugo passing a physical exam may have been the issue, which makes sense.