Matthew Pouliot

James Kaprielian

2015 MLB Draft: Picks 11-18 – Indians take Brady Aiken at No. 17

8 Comments

No. 11 pick – Reds – high school catcher Tyler Stephenson

Stephenson was the only catcher expected to have much chance of going in the top half of round one. He was also a legitimate prospect as a pitcher, but everyone was looking at him as a catcher, where his big arm will remain an asset. He offers big-time power potential, but he probably won’t turn into a particularly well-rounded hitter.

No. 12 pick – Marlins – high school first baseman Josh Naylor

The first Canadian taken, Naylor might offer the greatest power potential in the draft. He’s expected to be limited to first base, and he might not be much of an asset there. He could also be a big strikeout guy. The Marlins obviously have dreams of him protecting Giancarlo Stanton in the lineup someday, but it won’t happen anytime soon. He doesn’t even turn 18 for another two weeks.

No. 13 pick – Rays – high school outfielder Garrett Whitley

The Rays badly need this pick to work out after missing on so many first-rounders of late. Of course, this is the earliest they’ve picked since they grabbed Tim Beckham first overall in 2008. Whitley is a strong defensive center fielder with plenty of speed, and his swing should provide him with power in time.

No. 14 pick – Braves – high school left-hander Kolby Allard

The Braves are going with a West Coast guy in the first round for the first time since 1995, when they took, but didn’t sign, future Stanford quarterback Chad Hutchinson. Allard entered the year as a potential top-five pick, but a stress reaction in his back suffered in March damaged his stock. He could be a tough sign as a UCLA commit.

No. 15 pick – Brewers – high school outfielder Trent Clark

A left-handed hitter, Clark should hit for average and show at least doubles power. He could have gone even higher if teams were convinced he’d stay in center field, but it’s possible he’ll end up in left. The Brewers already have Tyrone Taylor and Monte Harrison as center field hopefuls, so it wouldn’t be such a disaster if Clark needs to slide over.

No. 16 pick – Yankees – UCLA right-hander James Kaprielian

Kaprielian is the biggest pitcher drafted so far, standing 6-foot-4. He should be one of the quickest movers among college pitchers, though he probably doesn’t have the ceiling of a Carson Fulmer. He’s just a low-90s guy with his fastball, but he has four pitches and fine command for someone his age.

No. 17 pick – Indians – left-hander Brady Aiken

The first overall pick from the 2014 draft is off the board. Aiken underwent Tommy John surgery in March, so he won’t begin pitching in the minors until next summer. He was viewed by most as the top talent in last year’s draft, and if his stuff comes all of the way back, he could prove to be a steal for the Indians. Obviously, there’s plenty of risk, but it’s a risk worth taking, considering that plenty of “safer” picks in this range don’t pan out.

No. 18 pick – Giants – Southern Nevada right-hander Phil Bickford

Bickford was the 10th overall pick out of high school in 2013, but he opted not to sign with the Blue Jays. His stuff has been up and down, more due to mechanical issues than any physical problems. He’s thrown in the mid-90s and shown a plus slider at times, and if he puts it all together, he could prove to be an excellent starter in time. Some believe he’s more likely to wind up in the pen.

2015 MLB Draft: Picks 6-10 – Twins pick college reliever sixth

Tyler Jay
7 Comments

No. 6 pick – Twins – Illinois left-hander Tyler Jay

The Twins are going with a guy who has made one start in three years in college. Jay had a 0.60 ERA and a 70/7 K/BB ratio in 60 1/3 innings for Illinois this season. He works in the mid-90s, uses two breaking balls and has the makings of a changeup, so there is plenty of potential as a starter if the Twins choose to use him there. Still, that he hasn’t done it before would only add to the injury risk. It’s possible the Twins will bring him to the majors as a reliever after the All-Star break and then move him to the rotation next year.

No. 7 pick – Red Sox – Arkansas outfielder Andrew Benintendi

Benintendi was one of the draft’s fastest risers after hitting .380/.489/.715 with 19 homers in 221 at-bats for Arkansas. He’s a potential plus defensive center fielder and a left-handed hitter with power in a rather compact 5-foot-10, 170-pound package. He probably won’t move as quickly as the college infielders drafted ahead of him — particularly not with all of the outfielders ahead of him in Boston — but his ceiling is as high as anyone’s.

No. 8 pick – White Sox – Vanderbilt right-hander Carson Fulmer

Factoring in performance and potential, Fulmer appeared to be the top college pitcher available, though two went ahead of him. The White Sox also stumbled into the best college pitcher available last year when Carlos Rodon fell to the third pick. Fulmer lacks ideal size, at 6-foot-0 and 195 pounds, which might have scared off the Rangers and Twins. There’s a good chance he would have been Boston’s pick had the Astros taken Bentintendi. Fulmer was 13-2 with a 1.82 ERA and a 152/46 K/BB ratio in 114 innings for the Commodores this season. He probably won’t move quite as quickly as Rodon, but he could still be one of the first players here to reach the majors.

No. 9 pick – Cubs – Cincinnati outfielder Ian Happ

Happ might offer the greatest offensive potential of the college players picked so far, but he’d also seem to have the least defensive value. He played some second base at Cincinnati, but most expect he’ll end up in left or right. Happ is a switch-hitter with considerable power and on-base ability. He’s another college product likely to move quickly for the Cubs, like Kris Bryant and Kyle Schwarber before him.

No. 10 pick – Phillies – high school shortstop Cornelius Randolph

The Phillies already have an awesome shortstop in 2013 first-rounder J.P Crawford, but that’s not much of an issue here. Randolph offers a very promising left-handed bat, but he’s going to need to move off short. Ideally, he’d go to second base, but third and the outfield are also possibility. The youngest player take in the top 10, Randolph just turned 18 last week. He should show power in time.

2015 MLB Draft: Picks 2-5 – Astros, Rockies take shortstops

Alex Bregman
2 Comments

No. 2 pick – Astros – Louisiana State shortstop Alex Bregman

On the day they called up 2012 first overall pick Carlos Correa, the Astros added another shortstop with the second overall selection, their compensation pick for not signing Brady Aiken as the first overall pick last year. Bregman doesn’t have the tools one might expect from a No. 2 overall pick, but he hits a bunch of liners and plays solid defense up the middle. With the Astros, he’s more of a threat to Jose Altuve’s spot at second than Correa’s at short. Altuve might eventually benefit from a move to the outfield anyway.

No. 3 pick – Rockies – high school shortstop Brendan Rogers

It’s all shortstops early, as the Rockies follow suit by going with the consensus No. 1 high school position player available. Rogers offers more power potential than either No. 1 pick Dansby Swanson or Bregman, and most expect that he’ll be able to remain at shortstop for the long term. Rogers is probably four years off, so this shouldn’t affect Troy Tulowitzki whatsoever. Most likely, Tulo will be gone from Colorado by the time Rogers is ready, and even if he’s still there, he probably won’t be a shortstop.

No. 4 pick – Rangers – UC Santa Barbara right-hander Dillon Tate

It sounded like the Rangers wanted to go with a college pitcher, and they had their choice of all of them, settling on Tate. A starter for the first time this year after closing last season, Tate was 8-5 with a 2.26 ERA and a 111/28 K/BB ratio for Santa Barbara. He has a mid-90s fastball and an excellent slider, but he lacks a reliable third pitch right now. Some believe he projects best as a reliever going forward, but the Rangers wouldn’t have picked him here if they felt that way.

No. 5 pick – Astros – high school outfielder Kyle Tucker

In at least a minor surprise, the Astros took the younger brother of their own Preston Tucker. Preston wasn’t regarded so highly out of high school and went to the University of Florida. Kyle is committed to the same school, but expectations are that he’ll sign. The first left-handed hitter selected, Tucker projects as a legitimate power bat. Also, whereas Preston is an adequate-at-best left fielder, Kyle should turn out to be above average in right field.