While thinking about Clayton Kershaw as the leading NL MVP candidate and Mike Trout as the leading AL MVP candidate it occurred to me that this could be one of the best MVP “pairings” ever.
I’m talking about the players’ standing in baseball history, rather than in their specific MVP-winning season. So, in a purely hypothetical world the best possible MVP “pairing” would be whoever you happen to believe are the two greatest players of all time. It could be, say, Babe Ruth and Barry Bonds. Or maybe Willie Mays and Ted Williams. Something like that. You get the idea, right?
Now, obviously Trout is only 23 years old and even Kershaw is only 26 years old, but few players their respective ages have ever accomplished what they have and in a couple decades it’s possible they’ll both be considered inner-circle Hall of Famers. But setting Kershaw and Trout aside, what are the best pairings ever to be named MVP in the same season?
After looking at the list of MVP winners here are my top five contenders for best MVP pairings ever:
1946: Ted Williams, Stan Musial
1957: Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron
1986: Roger Clemens, Mike Schmidt
1990: Barry Bonds, Rickey Henderson
2003: Barry Bonds, Alex Rodriguez
There are obviously a ton of other great pairings that could possibly crack the top five. Take a look at the full list and chime in with your choices.