Question of the Day: Choose your own MLB career

42 Comments

As part of my usual Twitter babbling I asked this question and was surprised by how varied the responses were, so I’ll open it up to the HBT crowd too.

If you could have a lengthy but mediocre MLB career–say more than a half-dozen seasons, but no big contracts or great years–would you choose to be a fifth starter, middle reliever, or platoon hitter?

I’m thinking the fifth starter/long reliever would be someone like Kevin Correia or Bruce Chen, the middle reliever would be someone like Brandon Lyon or Chad Qualls, and the platoon hitter would be someone like Reed Johnson or Jonny Gomes.

Players who have a sizable role on teams–so ruling out backup catchers, utility men, and left-handed specialists–but definitely far from household names and always at risk of being out of a job if they play poorly for a season or two.

So … what say you? (I’ll post my answer in the comments section.)

The Orioles seem pretty serious about moving Manny Machado

Getty Images
Leave a comment

LAKE BUENA VISTA, Fla. — Orioles third baseman Manny Machado will become a free agent after the 2018 season and there has been no suggestion that the O’s and their young star have worked on a contract extension, strongly suggesting that Machado will test the open market next offseason.

While the Orioles have not said much about keeping him or trading him, yesterday considerable chatter filtered out here at the Winter Meetings suggests that they are serious about trading him now in order to get more than a draft pick in return when he eventually leaves Baltimore.

Jon Heyman reported yesterday that the Cardinals were a possible landing spot, and others have speculated that, at the moment, they’re the frontrunners for his services. Buster Olney, in a development that would make people go insane, I suspect, that the Yankees have expressed interest. It seems highly unlikely, though, that the Orioles would trade Machado within the division. Even if they did, they’d likely expect a premium from the Yankees that they would be unwilling to pay, especially given that they could easily wait Machado out until he was a free agent next year and give up nothing but cash for him. A couple of days ago we noted that the Phillies had expressed interest and the Orioles were doing their due diligence with respect to their farm system.

As far as the possible parameters of a deal, Ken Rosenthal reported that the O’s hope to acquire at least two controllable young starters in return. That’s a high price for a one-year Machado rental, but it makes sense for the Orioles to ask it. For Machado’s part, he reportedly wants to return to his original position, shortstop. He does not have no-trade protection, of course, so that may be a wish that is not fulfilled.

Machado had a down 2017, hitting .259/.310/.471, but still hit 33 homers and drove in 95 runs. In the two years prior, however, he posted OPSs of .876 and .861, and he’s still just 25. All of which is to say that the price for a team to acquire him will be high, even if he’s entering his walk year.