Just as it should have been, Oakland’s Bob Melvin and Baltimore’s Buck Showalter claimed the top two spots on all 28 AL Manager of the Year ballots. Melvin, though, scored the win with 16 first-place votes to Showalter’s 12.
Rookie manager Robin Ventura of the White Sox came in third place with 12 third-place votes. Joe Maddon was fourth, followed by Joe Girardi. Jim Leyland and Ron Washington were named on two ballots apiece.
Melvin’s Athletics went 94-68 to win the AL West in his first full year at the helm. He replaced Bob Geren in June 2011 with the team off to a 27-36 start and then went 47-52 the rest of the way for a 74-88 finish.
Melvin also won the NL Manager of the Year award with the Diamondbacks in 2007, so he joins Davey Johnson, Tony La Russa, Jim Leyland, Bobby Cox and Lou Piniella as managers to win in both leagues.
That’s pretty good company for a manager whose lifetime winning percentage is .502 (634-628) in nine seasons.