Deep thoughts: what does it mean to “consider” someone for the MVP?

23 Comments

I tweeted this randomly a few minutes ago and got some good responses, so I figured I’d throw it out to the whole crowd:

I tire of the argument that goes like this: “Player X should get consideration for Honor Y!”

It could be the Hall of Fame. It could be a postseason award like the MVP or Cy Young.  Doesn’t matter.  But the argument usually comes in response to me (or someone) saying that a different player should be in or should win.

So I respond: OK, do you think your Player X should win or should get in?  And here’s where it kills me:  “No, but he should get consideration!”

What does that mean?  I mean, yes, I understand that there are downballot votes and that they matter for certain purposes, but if I’ve said I think Jose Bautista is the MVP, should I “consider” another guy?  In reaching my decision isn’t it understood that I’ve considered and rejected the other guys?  Same with the Hall of Fame: Jack Morris should be considered!  Should he be in? “No, but …” Then I guess he’s not worthy of any more consideration is, he?

Yes, this is rather navel-gazey, but I get annoyed at the ____ should be considered stuff.  Am I the only one? Am I being a jerk? Am I just simply getting this all wrong? None of those things are mutually-exclusive, of course.

Giants sign Austin Jackson to two-year, $6 million contract

Gregory Shamus/Getty Images
6 Comments

The Giants announced on Monday night the signing of outfielder Austin Jackson. According to Jon Heyman of FanRag Sports, it’s a two-year, $6 million deal with performance incentives that allow Jackson to earn up to an additional $2.5 million for a total of $8.5 million.

Jackson, who soon turns 31 years old, spent last season with the Indians. In 318 plate appearances, he hit .318/.387/.482 with seven home runs, 35 RBI, and 46 runs scored.

The Giants have been on the hunt for a center fielder and Jackson addresses that need relatively cheaply. Jackson will join Hunter Pence and newcomer Andrew McCutchen in the outfield.