With the Dodgers being officially eliminated from the playoff race yesterday Dylan Hernandez of the Los Angeles Times asked first baseman James Loney “what went wrong this season” and his response was interesting:
At times, teams played harder than us. I think we want to win. We want to finish it. We want to win the World Series. But the other teams are trying to do that, too. It’s not necessarily that if you have good players you’re going to win. You have to play as a team. Guys, hopefully, they see what we’ve gone through this year and people don’t want to be in this position next year.
Loney’s notion of the Dodgers having good players without winning and not playing as hard as other teams would sure seem to be an indictment of Joe Torre. Sure, you can point to players who underachieved or failed to hustle all the time, but ultimately isn’t it a manager’s job to deal with such things and keep them from getting out of control? Or, put another way, when a team is playing well isn’t that exactly the type of stuff managers are endlessly praised for?