The Indians and Pirates make a minor trade that got me wonderin'

4 Comments

The Pirates traded minor league catcher Luke Carlin to the Indians today for a player to be named later. That this is as minor a trade as can possibly be is illustrated by the fact that the most significant part of it — Carlin, the guy who was actually named — has really only had one nice minor league season, and that came on his fourth go-around in the Pacific Coast League. A prospect, he is not.

But there is some value here, and that’s that the transaction got me wondering how such a deal even comes together on this particular day at this particular time of year.

Who calls who first? Do the Indians really covet Carlin?  Did they simply need an organizational soldier at catcher and spun the wheel?  How long does it take for such deals to come together? Is the player to-be-named really just a fiction or an IOU designed to make it look like Carlin was just given away? What I mean is, do the Pirates just let this skate until they need their own organizational soldier sometime next year, or is the player to-be-named a to-do item on some intern’s desk?

Sorry, this is just the stuff I think about.

Aaron Boone interviewed for the Yankees manager job today

Getty Images
Leave a comment

MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch reports that ESPN broadcaster Aaron Boone interviewed for the Yankees’ manager job today. No word as to whether he hit a big home run.

Boone, an ESPN analyst, obviously has some history with the Yankees, but he has no coaching experience at any level. Joel Sherman of the New York Post wrote earlier this week of Boone that the Yankees “are intrigued if his charisma and passion can compensate for inexperience.” I’d say the answer to that question, whenever asked and in whatever context, is always “no,” but I suppose there’s a first time for everything.

So far the Yankees have interviewed Rob Thomson, Eric Wedge and Hensley Meulens. Yesterday Brian Cashman said there was no rush to fill the job, and that the Winter Meetings are not a deadline for the team in doing so.